Our Midwest Recipe BoxFamily recipes, shared through generations

Midwest Recipes by Ingredient

Cake Recipes

Celebration cakes, coffee cakes, cupcakes, frostings, and vintage favorites.

Official source card for Apple Butter CupcakesOfficial recipe card
Dessert

Apple Butter Cupcakes

A simple homemade cupcake recipe made with yellow cake mix, safflower oil, egg whites, and a sweet apple butter filling— baked until tender and cooled on a wire rack.

Official source card for Banana CakeOfficial recipe card
Dessert

Banana Cake

A soft, tender, old-fashioned banana cake.

Official source card for Banana CakeOfficial recipe card
Dessert

Banana Cake

A family recipe for Banana Cake, preserved in the official Our Midwest Recipe Box collection.

Official source card for Basic Butter Cream FrostingOfficial recipe card
Dessert

Basic Butter Cream Frosting

A classic, fluffy buttercream frosting made with vegetable shortening, butter, powdered sugar, cream or milk, vanilla, and salt, beaten until smooth and fluffy.

Official source card for Bearrific Buttercream FrostingOfficial recipe card
Dessert

Bearrific Buttercream Frosting

A family recipe for Bearrific Buttercream Frosting, preserved in the official Our Midwest Recipe Box collection.

Official source card for BrowniesOfficial recipe card
Dessert

Brownies

Rich, fudgy brownies with a glossy chocolate frosting perfectly sweet and packed with crunchy nuts.

Official source card for Butter Cream Frosting For Christmas CookiesOfficial recipe card
Dessert

Butter Cream Frosting For Christmas Cookies

A family recipe for Butter Cream Frosting For Christmas Cookies, preserved in the official Our Midwest Recipe Box collection.

Official source card for Butterscotch CookiesOfficial recipe card
Dessert

Butterscotch Cookies

A family recipe for Butterscotch Cookies, preserved in the official Our Midwest Recipe Box collection.

Official source card for Butterscotch-Granola Coffee CakeOfficial recipe card
Dessert

Butterscotch-Granola Coffee Cake

A sweet old-fashioned coffee cake made with flour, eggs, sour cream, butter, orange peel, granola, and a butterscotch filling—-layered in a square pan, baked until golden brown, then drizzled with glaze and sprinkled with chopped nuts.

Official source card for Carrot CakeOfficial recipe card
Dessert

Carrot Cake

A family recipe for Carrot Cake, preserved in the official Our Midwest Recipe Box collection.

Official source card for Carrot CakeOfficial recipe card
Dessert

Carrot Cake

Warmly spiced, moist, classic homemade carrot cake.

Official source card for Cheesecake SupremeOfficial recipe card
Dessert

Cheesecake Supreme

A rich and creamy cheesecake with a smooth sour cream topping.

Official source card for Chocolate Chip Cream FrostingOfficial recipe card
Dessert

Chocolate Chip Cream Frosting

A light, fluffy homemade frosting made with chilled whipping cream, powdered sugar, vanilla, and chocolate chips—-beaten until stiff and folded togetherfor an easy sweet topping.

Official source card for Chocolate FrostingOfficial recipe card
Dessert

Chocolate Frosting

A rich homemade chocolate frosting made with Crisco, cocoa, milk, vanilla, salt, and powdered sugar--beaten until smooth and creamy for frosting cakes.

Official source card for Collector's Cocoa CakeOfficial recipe card
Dessert

Collector's Cocoa Cake

A family recipe for Collector's Cocoa Cake, preserved in the official Our Midwest Recipe Box collection.

Official source card for Favorite Coffee CakeOfficial recipe card
Dessert

Favorite Coffee Cake

A classic homemade coffee cake with a crumb topping, baked warm and served fresh.

Official source card for Fresh Apple CakeOfficial recipe card
Dessert

Fresh Apple Cake

A warmly spiced homemade apple cake with honey,apples,and pecans.

Official source card for Fudgy Chocolate CakeOfficial recipe card
Dessert

Fudgy Chocolate Cake

A family recipe for Fudgy Chocolate Cake, preserved in the official Our Midwest Recipe Box collection.

Official source card for Grandma Pickel's Treasure Chest BarsOfficial recipe card
Dessert

Grandma Pickel's Treasure Chest Bars

A sweet old-fashioned cherry chocolate bar made with brown sugar, white sugar, butter, eggs, milk, flour, chocolate chips, and maraschino cherries-finished with a warm brown-butter frosting.

Official source card for Grandmas Chocolate CakeOfficial recipe card
Dessert

Grandmas Chocolate Cake

A rich, old-fashioned chocolate cake made with brown sugar, cocoa, and a creamy boiled chocolate frosting.

Official source card for Italian Cream CakeOfficial recipe card
Dessert

Italian Cream Cake

A family recipe for Italian Cream Cake, preserved in the official Our Midwest Recipe Box collection.

Official source card for One Bowl Butter Cream FrostingOfficial recipe card
Dessert

One Bowl Butter Cream Frosting

A quick and creamy buttercream frosting made in one bowl no cooking needed! Perfect for cakes, cupcakes, and cookies.

Official source card for Peanut Butter CakeOfficial recipe card
Dessert

Peanut Butter Cake

A family recipe for Peanut Butter Cake, preserved in the official Our Midwest Recipe Box collection.

Official source card for Sour Cream DropsOfficial recipe card
Main Dish

Sour Cream Drops

Tender old-fashioned sour cream drop cookies made with margarine, sugar, egg, vanilla, flour, soda, salt, and sour cream—mixed into a soft dough, dropped onto a cookie sheet, baked until set, then cooled and frosted with orange frosting.

Official source card for Speedy Chocolate Chip CheesecakeOfficial recipe card
Dessert

Speedy Chocolate Chip Cheesecake

A family recipe for Speedy Chocolate Chip Cheesecake, preserved in the official Our Midwest Recipe Box collection.

Official source card for Spring Breeze CheesecakeOfficial recipe card
Dessert

Spring Breeze Cheesecake

A light old-fashioned no-bake cheesecake made with cream cheese, sugar, sour cream, vanilla, whipped topping, and a graham cracker crust chilled until set and garnished with fresh strawberries if desired.

Official source card for Strawberry ShortcakeOfficial recipe card
Dessert

Strawberry Shortcake

A family recipe for Strawberry Shortcake, preserved in the official Our Midwest Recipe Box collection.

Official source card for Yellow CakeOfficial recipe card
Dessert

Yellow Cake

A classic homemade yellow cake made with flour, sugar, baking powder, Crisco, eggs, milk, and vanillamixed into a smooth batter and baked until tender and golden.